John Woo's "Silent Night" elicits a mixture of anticipation and trepidation—a cinematic concoction that could have soared yet hardly finds its wings. With the pedigree of Woo's direction combined with the production force behind "John Wick", one might expect a palpable pulse of thrills to resonate through the narrative very much like a choir on Christmas Eve. Yet, as the story unfolds, it seems as though the carol has been hummed rather than sung, leaving us more fatigued than invigorated.

The revenge tale sets the stage with Joel Kinnaman as a torment-ridden father, who, following the harrowing death of his son, enters a monkish crusade for vengeance. It’s a scenario rife with potential for deep emotion and intense action. While Kinnaman brings a certain brooding gravitas to the role, the development of his character feels like a missed opportunity. The transformation from grieving parent to an instrument of retribution seems as silent as his own voice—robbed of powerful articulation by the plot's shortcomings.

Woo's craftsmanship with action sequences offers glimmers of his trademark brilliance, stitching together well-choreographed bouts that are both stylish and sleek. However, these snatches of cinematic elegance seem superimposed onto an otherwise disjointed narrative. They are moments of visual celebration that seek to mask the film's broader narrative deficits, but they're a distraction rather than a foundation, failing to compensate for the lack of depth and connectivity between the set pieces.

The script, inadvertently or not, sidesteps the emotional heft and opts for what comes across as hollow bombast—a misstep that leaves a chasm between the audience’s expectations and the film's reality. "Silent Night" endeavours to redefine its genre, yet, instead of trailblazing, it walks familiar grounds—grounds we've tread too often, and with more compelling guides.

Overall, "Silent Night" scores a 6 out of 10. A score that acknowledges the flashes of Woo's stylistic flair and Kinnaman's dedicated performance, but also recognizes the film's inability to deliver the pulsating heart of a true action thriller. This was a chance to reignite the flame of the genre's potential, to craft a poignant tale of loss and revenge, but sadly, it fizzles out, delivering mere embers rather than an inferno of excitement and engagement. For a director of John Woo's caliber, we can't help but mourn what might have been—an opus instead of a somewhat muffled chorus.