If you're a fan of grand historical dramas that paint the past with strokes of today's cinematic prowess, "Napoleon 2023" will likely march right into your good graces. It’s a film that takes us through the tumultuous journey of the famed French Emperor Napoleon Bonaparte with Joaquin Phoenix at the helm delivering a robust performance worthy of the character’s complex persona.

Right from the start, the movie serves up a visual feast. Let's talk about the production—Ridley Scott is no stranger to orchestrating sprawling epics, and he ensures that every frame of this film is a testament to his legendary filmmaking skills. The battle sequences erupt onto the screen with such authenticity and precision; you can't help but feel the ground shake with the cavalry charge. It’s clear that Scott hasn't lost his touch when it comes to crafting expansive, real-world cinematic canvases.

Joaquin Phoenix, clad in military regalia, channels the spirit of Napoleon with an intensity that grips you. The relationship between Napoleon and Josephine is painted with broad emotional strokes, highlighting their passionate, tumultuous, and strategic partnership. The film takes creative liberties, yes, but in doing so it allows a 'new look of history' to emerge—one that’s more accessible and, at times, more thrilling.

However, not all is perfect on the battlefield of this film's execution. There's a sense of 'could have been' lingering in the air. Although the movie sets out to redefine the epic historical genre with modern sensibilities, it sometimes stumbles, losing the chance to dig deeper into the intricacies of Napoleon's psyche or the era's complex political landscape. These narrative gaps create an opportunity lost, leading to a slight sense of disappointment for those eager to truly delve into the mind of the iconic leader.

This leads me to one of the film's more questionable choices—the inclusion of scenes of a more intimate nature that seem disconnected from the story’s central narrative. These scenes may strike some as unnecessary, detracting from the film’s otherwise rich tapestry by leaning too heavily on sensuality rather than substance. In a film so packed with potential for gripping drama and character exploration, these moments can feel jarringly out of place, as if added merely for shock value rather than narrative necessity.

In conclusion, "Napoleon 2023" is a lavish portrayal of an enigmatic figure set against the canvas of history, equipped with strong performances and top-tier production value. It left something to be desired in its depth of storytelling and character development but nonetheless stands as a powerful, albeit flawed, piece of cinema. It's certainly worth watching for the spectacle and Phoenix's magnetic portrayal, earning a solid 7 out of 10 on our cinematic scorecard.